Man.
“South Park” normally makes it a priority to shock, though they’re sort of past that “controversial” stage. Not much of its shock value really holds true because true fans expect the worst.
I’m not sure anyone anticipated what we saw on Wednesday night, at least during the first five minutes. I’ve caught flak for it from a few people, but I maintain that it was one of the show’s finest moments ever, based solely on laughs and surprise.
When the little ginger kid who reads the morning announcements is mistaken for a 42-year-old truck driver by a jealous husband, it just goes to an insane place, thanks primarily to Trey Parker’s unbelievable voice work. “SHYEAH RIGHT!!!”
Some say they crossed a bit of a line, given the recent history of school shootings, and that’s hard to argue. But it made me laugh…hard. I can’t apologize for finding it funny, maybe especially because they revealed it to be a ginger kid.
What I wasn’t crazy about this week: the Casey Miller kid. It was an easy gag that had its best moment at the end of the episode when he finally got to read the announcements. I knew the kid’s voice would be a great broadcasting voice, but I kind of wanted him to be more of a smooth baritone.
What really worked for me: the Smurf thing paid off in a big way. I honestly didn’t know where they were going with it, and it only finally hit me once Cartman was staring at the Avatar poster. I never even thought of James Cameron’s movie as “Dances with Smurfs” until this episode, and that’s brilliant. I do stand by my initial assessment of the blue things. They’re inspired by the Shawn Bradley Monstar in Space Jam.
The Glenn Beck thing was just so-so, but Cartman’s final line was a killer. Again, this was a case of Parker and Matt Stone making fun of someone that’s just too easy for them (like Michael Jackson). They’re better at catching us off guard, nailing a deserving figure who hasn’t gotten the treatment yet.
This mini-season has only delivered greatness sparingly, but it’s been sufficient. I’ve never really not liked an episode outright. There’s always enough material to merit a few genuine laughs. We got a really strong start to season 13, but its latter half has prevented it from reaching the heights of seasons 6-9.